Dhaka 26 September, 2026

US-Iran War: Is Pakistan a Real Peacemaker?

Shamil Shams, Deutsche Welle

Publish : 14 Apr 2026, 10:50 AM
Pakistan maintains close ties with both Iran and the US. Photo: REUTERS

Although the high-stakes US-Iran talks in Islamabad on April 11-12 failed to deliver a peace deal, Pakistan's proactive role in mediating a global conflict was much appreciated internationally.

Not only did the Iranian delegation thank Islamabad for facilitating the talks, but US President Donald Trump also lauded Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and Field Marshal Asim Munir for their efforts.

"They are very extraordinary men and continuously thank me for saving 30 to 50 million lives in what would have been a horrendous war with India," Trump said in a post on social media.

For the moment, the negotiations between Iran and the US are stalled, but there is still a chance that they could be revived in the coming days before the ceasefire deadline on April 22.

"The simple fact is that we need to see an affirmative commitment that they will not seek a nuclear weapon, and they will not seek the tools that would enable them to quickly achieve a nuclear weapon," Vice President JD Vance, who was heading the US delegation, told reporters in Islamabad on Sunday.

Regional hostilities with Afghanistan, India
Some political experts are of the view that to be considered a genuine peacemaker, Islamabad needs to improve ties with some of its neighboring countries, particularly Afghanistan, with which it says it is in an "open war," and India, its longtime rival with whom it engaged in a brief but deadly war in May last year.

image

"Ironically, while Pakistan was playing the role of a peacemaker internationally, China hosted a week-long round of talks between Kabul and Islamabad to end ongoing hostilities between the two," Farooq Sulehria, a Pakistani political analyst, told DW.

Ties between the Taliban rulers in Kabul and Islamabad have deteriorated since the Islamist group seized power in Afghanistan in 2021 following the withdrawal of US-led international troops from the war-torn country. Since last year, Kabul and Islamabad have been engaged in a direct war with the Pakistani air force, which is targeting what it describes as "militant hideouts" inside Afghanistan.

Ties with India remain fraught after the May 2025 military escalation over the Pahalgam attacks in India-administered Kashmir.

"This shows that Pakistan is not a peacemaker either by ideology or by necessity. The ideological basis of the Pakistani state rests on India's animosity. The current tension with Kabul is partly an extension of this India-centric approach as the Taliban regime is cozying up to New Delhi, making Islamabad furious. Hence, there is a contradiction in Pakistan's role as a global peacemaker," Sulehria underlined.

'Different responses to different pressures'
But Fatemeh Aman, an Iran-Pakistan expert and senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, argues that although Pakistan's role in negotiating the US-Iran war and its hostile ties with Kabul and New Delhi might appear like a dichotomy, it is in reality "different responses to different pressures."

image

"While the mediation in US–Iran tension creates diplomatic space, managing Afghanistan is about stability. This approach reflects constraint, not a double standard. Pakistan wants regional relevance but faces problems it cannot easily solve," she told DW.

"This situation is not as contradictory as it seems. Pakistan is handling two different realities. Its ties with Iran and the US are about diplomacy and staying relevant with low risk. Afghanistan, however, is an immediate security concern involving militancy, border instability, and internal pressure. So, it's less a contradiction and more a two-level approach: influence abroad, control at home," Aman stressed.

Political analyst Raza Rumi agrees: "Islamabad's engagement with the US-Iran situation and its tensions with Afghanistan operate in different contexts. The former is low-risk diplomacy where Pakistan can play a facilitating role; the latter is an immediate security challenge shaped by militancy and border instability. This approach reflects necessity and opportunity in one case, and proximity and vulnerability in the other," Rumi told DW.

He said that what appeared to be a dichotomy was actually the result of different policy imperatives, explaining that states adapt their policies based on geography, threats, and leverage. He added that Pakistan could engage diplomatically in the US-Iran space without direct risk, whereas Afghanistan involved active security concerns and therefore required a different approach.

Pakistan's domestic unrest
Experts also point to the Pakistani government's crackdown on Former PM Imran Khan's Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party at home and the military operations against militants in western Balochistan and northwestern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa provinces.

image

Resolving domestic conflicts could boost the government's image as an entity that prefers dialogue over force, they say.

"Peace and reconciliation in Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa provinces are imperative," Sulehria said. "A functioning democracy is vital for Pakistan to brand itself as a global peacemaker. Such a change, however, is highly unlikely under the present dispensation," he added.

The analyst also criticizes the imprisonment of Khan, calling it "anti-democratic."

"Foreign policy mirrors domestic politics," he underlined.

Rumi believes Pakistan faces "structural constraints" in dealing with complex issues, adding that Islamabad's actions are "shaped less by choice and more by the limits of its strategic environment."

Follow google news channel to get RTV news Google News
Four Nuclear Powers and Six Others Unite Against the US
Four nuclear-armed nations—China, Russia, India, and Pakistan—have joined forces alongside six other influential states to challenge Washington's dominance and unilateral hegemony in global geopolitics.
Four Nuclear Powers and Six Others Unite Against the US
Suicide Bombing in Pakistan Leaves At Least 14 Dead
At least 14 people were killed and another 18 injured in a suicide bombing outside a police station in Pakistan’s northwestern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province. The attack took place on Sunday (August 2) in the Kabal area of Swat District. According to Regional Police Officer Fida Hussain, the casualties include five police officers, eight civilians, and the suspected suicide bomber. At the time of the blast, a gathering of local residents in support of the police was underway in the area. However, it could not be immediately confirmed whether the gathering was the primary target of the attack. Police stated that operations have been launched to identify and arrest accomplices involved in the bombing. Meanwhile, the banned militant group Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) has claimed responsibility for the attack. Following the incident, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif expressed profound grief, offered condolences to the families of the victims, and directed authorities to bring those responsible to justice swiftly. Militant attacks have surged in Pakistan’s border regions in recent months, with security forces and police personnel frequently targeted. While the Pakistani government has blamed the Afghan Taliban for the security situation, Kabul has consistently denied the allegations.(Source: Reuters)
Suicide Bombing in Pakistan Leaves At Least 14 Dead
Avalanche Claims Lives of 10 Climbers in Pakistan, Including Nirmal Purja
Renowned British-Nepali mountaineer Nirmal Purja, popularly known as "Nimsdai," and nine other climbers have all been killed in an avalanche on Broad Peak, one of the world's highest mountains located in northern Pakistan. Despite adverse weather conditions, rescue teams are making maximum efforts to recover the bodies, according to the latest reports. On Saturday (August 1), Purja’s expedition company, Elite Exped, confirmed the tragic news. In a statement, Elite Exped stated that the mountaineering world has lost one of its finest climbers while expressing deep condolences to the families of all the victims. "Words cannot alleviate the pain of this unimaginable loss," the statement read. The 10-member climbing team went missing in an avalanche while ascending Broad Peak in Pakistan last Thursday. Recovery helicopters were initially grounded due to adverse weather conditions. On Friday, rescuers located the bodies of four members and successfully retrieved three of them. On Saturday, search operations for the remaining members resumed with the assistance of military helicopters. Irfan Arshad Khan, President of the Alpine Club of Pakistan, said, "The deaths of these brave climbers, drawn from different countries by the call of the mountains, are an irreparable loss to the global mountaineering community." He paid tribute to the Pakistani military, civilian rescue personnel, and Sherpas participating in the operation. "While the beauty of the mountains inspires us, such tragedies remind us of the immense risks involved in expeditions across the rugged peaks of the Himalayas and Karakoram," he added. Local police official Tahir Khan stated that the body of Omani mountaineer Nathira Al Harthy is being sent to Islamabad. Meanwhile, the bodies of American climber Mallory Gayet and Nepal's Bahadur Gurung have been placed at a hospital in Skardu, the main city of Pakistan's northern Gilgit-Baltistan region. In a statement, Gayet's family said, "Mallory was a vibrant person deeply loved by her family and friends. We will miss her terribly." Legacy of Nirmal PurjaThe expedition was led by Nirmal Purja, a Nepal-born former British soldier widely known as "Nimsdai." In 2019, he set a world record by conquering all 14 of the world's highest peaks in just 189 days. His extraordinary feat was chronicled in the Netflix documentary 14 Peaks: Nothing Is Impossible. Honoring his memory, Purja’s organization noted that he was a man who inspired millions through his courage and humility, remaining steadfast in his belief that human potential far exceeds our imagination. Meanwhile, Mallory Gayet was attempting to summit her first 8,000-meter peak in Pakistan. According to the Moving Mountains website, the expedition was also set to be the final mountain journey for Sakhi, a guide, geographer, and high-altitude photographer who had successfully climbed several major global peaks. Experts note that climbing expeditions in northern Pakistan frequently encounter such tragedies due to avalanches, ice and rock falls, extreme altitudes, and rapidly changing weather patterns. Broad Peak, situated in northern Pakistan near the Pakistan-China border, is one of the world's 14 "eight-thousanders" (peaks exceeding 8,000 meters in height).
Avalanche Claims Lives of 10 Climbers in Pakistan, Including Nirmal Purja
47 Killed, Including 3 Police Officers, in Anti-Terrorism Operations in Pakistan
Security forces have launched extensive anti-terrorism operations across Pakistan. Based on intelligence inputs, at least 44 terrorists have been killed in separate clashes over the past 24 hours, while three police officers—including a Deputy Superintendent of Police (DSP)—have lost their lives in militant attacks. According to the Anadolu Agency, the incidents took place in Pakistan's Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan provinces. Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi stated that late Wednesday night, terrorists launched an attack on a police checkpost in the Hangu district of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, killing three police officers, including a DSP. The Interior Minister added that security forces repelled the attack through a retaliatory operation, killing eight terrorists. Police reported that 18 police officers were injured in the clash. Read More Helicopter Crash in Argentina Kills Seven Earlier, the Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR), the media wing of the Pakistan Army, announced that 24 terrorists were killed in multiple operations in the Khyber district near the Afghan border. In a separate operation in Balochistan's Nushki district, another eight terrorists were killed. The ISPR statement said, "A large cache of weapons, ammunition, and explosives was recovered and destroyed during the operations. Search operations are ongoing to apprehend the remaining terrorists." Police further reported that four more suspected terrorists were killed during ongoing operations in the Swat district of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, where searches are also underway. Swat, a popular tourist destination in Pakistan, was once a stronghold for militant groups. The government regained control of the valley following a military operation in 2009. Terrorist attacks have surged in Pakistan in recent years. Islamabad claims that these attacks are orchestrated by the Afghanistan-based Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), though Kabul has denied the allegation.
47 Killed, Including 3 Police Officers, in Anti-Terrorism Operations in Pakistan
Will Pakistan Intervene amid Houthi Attacks on Saudi Ships?
Pakistan condemned attacks on Saudi oil tankers in the Red Sea by Iran-backed Yemeni Houthi militia last week as the conflict in the Middle East threatens to expand. In a statement, the Pakistani Foreign Ministry warned that any Houthi threat to Pakistani maritime interests in the Red Sea could be met with the "lawful use of force." Pakistan enjoys a trade and security relationship with Saudi Arabia, and Pakistani-flagged vessels frequent Saudi ports in the Red Sea. Last September, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia signed a mutual defense agreement that contains a "collective security" clause, meaning attack on one country is considered an attack on both. After the Houthis launched missiles at southern Saudi Arabia last week, Pakistan's Foreign Ministry expressed its "unwavering commitment" to the security pact. At the same time, Pakistan also has ties with Iran, and has been a key mediator between Tehran and Washington to end the Iran war. Any military act against the Iran-backed Houthis could place Islamabad in one of the most complicated foreign policy situations it has faced in years. Pakistan's tightrope between Saudis and IranHistorically, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan have shared close military and strategic relations. Pakistani military generals and advisers have aided the kingdom for decades. Farea Al-Muslimi, a Yemen expert at London-based think tank Chatham House, told DW that Pakistani troops are already in Yemen in support of the Saudis, "carrying out security and training-related duties alongside Saudi forces." A Pakistani official DW spoke to categorically denied this claim. Nevertheless, if Houthi attacks on oil tankers and commercial shipping escalate in the Red Sea, Saudi Arabia could turn to Pakistan for help. "Pakistan is one of Riyadh's closest defense partners, and their mutual defense pact makes such a request plausible. Having also come under Iranian attack, Saudi Arabia may increasingly look to Islamabad for military assistance if it feels under growing security pressure," Michael Kugelman, senior fellow at the Washington-based Atlantic Council, told DW. However, Pakistan's improving ties with Iran and its mediation to end the US-Iran conflict could complicate any Pakistani military role on Saudi Arabia's behalf.  Pakistan Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman embrace after signing a defense agreement in September 2025 "Pakistan and Iran have a complicated relationship based on the calculation of tactical gains by either side. In any case, Pakistan has warned Iran several times that in case of conflict it will support Saudi Arabia," Ayesha Siddiqa, a Pakistani military analyst and senior fellow at King's College London, told DW. After a period of unprecedented tensions in 2024, when Iran and Pakistan exchanged cross-border missile strikes, the neighbors have since rebuilt diplomatic relations and strengthened cooperation against militant groups operating along their shared border. "Limited military support for Saudi Arabia would not necessarily rupture Pakistan's ties with Iran. But at a time when Islamabad is trying to present itself as a neutral mediator, expanding arms support to Riyadh could deepen Tehran's suspicions and undermine Pakistan's diplomatic role," Kugelman said. How much support can Pakistan give?If Saudi Arabia seeks assistance, analysts say Pakistan's contribution would most likely focus on protecting Saudi interests rather than joining offensive operations. "The preference would be for defensive engagement, as expanding operations in the Red Sea may prove too risky," said Siddiqa. Such an approach could include intelligence sharing, air-defense cooperation, maritime surveillance and protecting critical Saudi infrastructure, allowing Pakistan to support Riyadh without joining offensive operations. "Despite its deep military ties and mutual defense pact with Saudi Arabia, Pakistan is unlikely to provide arms or troops. Islamabad is focused on preventing regional escalation and preserving its role as a mediator in the Iran conflict, making any military support for Riyadh politically risky and potentially damaging to its ties with Tehran," said Kugelman. Will Saudi Arabia escalate?Saudi Arabia has exercised considerable restraint since winding down its large-scale military campaign in Yemen. However, repeated attacks on oil infrastructure and commercial shipping may eventually force Riyadh to respond more aggressively. "Continued Houthi attacks on Saudi vessels could prompt Riyadh to abandon its restraint and launch a military response," said Al-Muslimi. King's College analyst Siddiqa said it is not clear that Saudi Arabia currently has the capacity to fight a prolonged sub-conventional war against the Houthis. "While it may intensify air strikes, more bombardment alone is unlikely to achieve the objective of making the kingdom more secure," she said.  The analysts agreed Islamabad will likely back maritime security and freedom of navigation while avoiding direct strikes on Houthi targets amid the looming US-Iran conflict. But if the Red Sea conflict escalates, staying neutral may become increasingly difficult as pressure from Riyadh and Tehran grows. "The trajectory of the conflict with Iran will shape Saudi Arabia's tolerance for Houthi attacks," said Kugelman. "If the current pause between the US and Iran holds, Riyadh is likely to wait out the attacks rather than escalate. But Saudi Arabia will continue to view Pakistan as a key security partner because Houthi attacks are unlikely to stop, even if the Iran conflict ends," he added.
Will Pakistan Intervene amid Houthi Attacks on Saudi Ships?
Read More
Pakistan's Sharif Rails against India, Praises Trump at UNGA
'Iran Will Never Bow Down', Pezeshkian Warns Trump at UN
CNN and Two Other Outlets Sue Trump Administration to Restore White House Access
Donald Trump Plans to Form New 'AI Force'